Appeal Court firmly dismisses Commissioner's merger injunction appeal

Shawn C.D. Neylan

On January 22, 2008, the Federal Court of Appeal dismissed an appeal by the Commissioner of Competition (the Commissioner) of the Competition Tribunal's refusal to grant an injunctive order under s. 100 of the Competition Act. The order would have delayed the closing of Labatt Brewing Company Limited's acquisition of Lakeport Brewing Income Fund. The Tribunal's decision not to grant the injunctive order was a landmark in Canadian merger review law. It has now been upheld by the Court in a resounding manner, as the Court concluded it did not need to hear submissions from Labatt's counsel. The Court is expected to issue reasons for its decision in due course. We will send out an update when those reasons are issued.

Shawn Neylan and Katherine Kay of Stikeman Elliott were competition counsel to Lakeport (until its acquisition by Labatt), successfully defending the Commissioner's request to the Tribunal for an injunction in the original proceedings.

Canada Pipe case settled, abuse of dominance provision remains unresolved

Kevin Rushton

On December 20, 2007, the Competition Bureau announced the end to five years of litigation concerning the Stocking Distributor Program (SDP) of Canada Pipe Company Ltd. with the filing of a consent agreement with the Competition Tribunal. The consent agreement pre-empts the Tribunal's re-determination proceedings in the case.  As a result, the proper legal approach to the Competition Act's abuse of dominance provision, in light of the Commissioner of Competition's position in the proceedings, has yet to be resolved.

Continue Reading...

Consent agreement reached in paint company merger

Jennifer Macarthur

On December 14, 2006, the Competition Bureau announced that a consent agreement was filed with the Competition Tribunal in relation to the acquisition by Akzo Nobel N.V. (Nobel) of Imperial Chemical Industries (ICI). Nobel's paint brands include Sico, PARA, Béntonel and Crown Diamond, while ICI's brands include CIL, Glidden, Colour Your World and Ralph Lauren.

The consent agreement requires Nobel to divest certain paint brands, including the PARA business and the Crown Diamond brand, and related assets in Canada in order to address the Bureau's competition concerns in the supply of paint resulting from the acquisition of ICI. In addition, the consent agreement requires Nobel, for a period of five years, to cease a program in Quebec that rewards retailers for carrying only Nobel brands or for the number of Nobel brands purchased in Quebec.